EXTRA BRACE?

[Lex]

Starting new thread on the 58 Gibson. This is the one where the neck collapsed into the sound hole.

I feel things are going well. All but one brace have been removed and glued. cracks are filled. My question is.... Do I need to put an extra brace between the neck block and the first brace?

If yes, what length, thickness and width should it be?

Thanks

Lex

[Taffy Evans]

Hi, if it was me and I thought that area still week I would at least place a brace the same size as #1half way between neck block and first brace. Keep in mind the ends of the new brace need to be supported at its ends, as are the others.

I just did the same repair on an acoustic bass, the action was 23mm at the 12th fret. I managed to get it all done through the sound hole. I modified the neck block, replace original brace, and added an extra brace.
Good luck with yours.
Taff

[Lex]

Hey Taff, so as you know the other braces were glued under the kerfing. when removing the braces i had to cut one end on each to remove them. are you saying I need to support those somehow as well? How do I do that?

Thank you

Lex

[Taffy Evans]

Ha ha, I thought I’d give you time to work it out. I’m not able to post photos at the moment as away from office.
I have repaired many guitar tops due the them collapsing because of unsupported braces. 
Back soon

Taff

[Taffy Evans]

Hi again, back at the workshop.

Did you work out the problem Lex?..

Here are a couple of pics to help you out. Think outside the box to adapt these ideas to your issue.

I use different methods for different guitars.

Here are two methods on the same guitar. the supports are mine - THE MESSY REPAIR WAS BY SOMEBODY ELSE.

This is what can happen if braces are not supported at their ends. But the glue may still have given way, and not being checked into the kerfing made for easier removal, but not so easy replacement.

Same old X brace cleaned up ready to go back in, with supports of course.

These repairs are all done through the soundhole, you would get a neater job with the back off.

[Lex]

okay, I have so idea’s running through my mind now. Thanks for the help. I will post a pic when I get it done. The bracing that is. I really appreciate the help. Some Luthiers do not want to share. 
Best Regards 

Lex

[Taffy Evans]

I have been there. When first started I traveled 4000km with a list of twelve luthiers in Australia, and after giving them a heads-up phone call, only three gave me time of day.

It made me more determined to find my own solutions. And now we have the internet. Even my customers are experts now. Haha.

Taff